Your Client Will See 3.6%. That Isn’t the Number That Matters.
Every fall, the same call comes in. A client has read that Social Security is going up, has done the math on the headline number, and wants to know what to do with the raise. The honest answer this year is that the headline number is the least actionable figure in the announcement, and one of the numbers clients care about most has not been published yet.
On October 14, 2026, the Social Security Administration announced a 3.6% cost-of-living adjustment for 2027 [1][2]. SSA estimates the average retired worker's monthly benefit will rise from $2,095 to $2,170 starting in January 2027 [2]. Beneficiaries can see their personal notice in their my Social Security account, and mailed notices follow in December [2]. Supplemental Security Income recipients see the increase first, in the payment dated December 31, 2026 [2].
Three other numbers in the same release matter more for planning, and a fourth is still missing.
The taxable maximum: a raise in reverse for high earners
The maximum earnings subject to the Social Security payroll tax rises from $184,500 to $192,300 [1][3]. For a client earning above the cap, that is $7,800 more wages taxed at 6.2%, or $483.60 more withheld over the year, matched by the employer. A self-employed client above the cap pays both halves, $967.20 more. It is not a large number, but it is the first change many high earners will notice in January, and it belongs in withholding and estimated-tax planning now rather than in a surprised April conversation.
The earnings test: the most misunderstood rule in the program
For clients who claim before full retirement age and keep working, the 2027 annual exempt amount is $25,560 ($2,130 a month), up from $24,480 [1]. SSA withholds $1 of benefits for every $2 earned above that amount. In the calendar year a client reaches full retirement age, the limit rises to $67,920 ($5,660 a month), the withholding drops to $1 for every $3, and only earnings before the month the client reaches full retirement age count [1]. From that month on, there is no earnings test at all [1].
The rule causes two predictable mistakes. Some clients stop working, or turn down hours, to avoid a "penalty" that is not a penalty: benefits withheld under the earnings test are not lost, because SSA recalculates the benefit at full retirement age to credit the months withheld. Others claim early, keep a full salary, and are startled when checks stop for several months. Both are planning failures, and both are avoidable with one conversation.
ADVISOR SCENARIO
Consider a hypothetical client, 63, who claimed benefits this year and has been offered a consulting contract worth $45,560 in 2027. She asks whether the 3.6% COLA means she should take it. The COLA is irrelevant to the decision; the earnings test is not. She would be $20,000 above the exempt amount, so SSA would withhold about $10,000 of benefits during the year. Her advisor explains that the withheld benefits are credited back through a higher benefit at full retirement age, models the cash-flow gap the withholding creates, and compares it with suspending the claim entirely. The conversation she needed was about the contract and the earnings test, not the raise.
The number nobody can give yet
For most retirees, the Medicare Part B premium is deducted from the Social Security payment, so what a client actually nets depends on it. As of this writing, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has not announced the 2027 Part B premium. Projections are circulating, and some sites describe them as final. They are not. Clients with higher incomes face income-related surcharges on top of the standard premium, which makes the gap between the COLA and the net change larger for them.
The credibility move is to say this plainly: "Your gross benefit is going up 3.6%. Your net deposit depends on a Medicare number that has not been released. When it is, we will show you the actual figure." A client who hears that from you will trust the next number you give them.
A short script for the COLA call
- Translate the percentage into dollars. Use the client's own benefit, not the average. A 3.6% increase on their January payment is the number they will see.
- Name what is still unknown. The 2027 Part B premium had not been announced as of this writing. Do not quote a net figure until it is.
- Check anyone still working. For early claimants, run the 2027 earnings test against expected wages, and remember the different limit in the year they reach full retirement age [1].
- Flag the taxable maximum for high earners. Adjust withholding or estimated payments for the $192,300 wage base [1].
- Revisit the tax picture. A higher benefit can change how much of a client's Social Security is taxable, because the income thresholds for taxing benefits are not indexed to inflation. Coordinate with the client's tax preparer before year-end.
Bottom Line
The COLA is the number in every headline, and it is the one clients can do the least about. The planning value sits in the rules underneath it: who pays more payroll tax, who will have checks withheld, and what Medicare will take before the deposit arrives. Advisors who use the November call to address those, and who are candid that one figure is still outstanding, turn a routine annual notice into one of the most useful conversations of the year.
For CFP® candidates, the earnings test and the taxable maximum are exactly the kind of mechanics clients will ask about in practice. Knowing how they work, and how often they are misunderstood, is part of what makes the advice worth paying for.
Sources
[1] Social Security Administration, "2027 Social Security Changes" (COLA fact sheet), October 2026. ssa.gov
[2] Social Security Administration, "COLA 2027: Social Security Announces 3.6 Percent Benefit Increase for 2027," October 14, 2026. ssa.gov
[3] Journal of Accountancy, "Social Security wage base and COLA announced for 2027," October 2026. journalofaccountancy.com
